Jump to content


Where classical school and homeschool teachers talk.



Discussion Starts Here.

For the Children's Sake.

Learn from Others.

Add Your Voice to the Conversation.

Glad You Are Here.

Give Us Your Question.


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


DianaC last won the day on December 22 2018

DianaC had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

7 Neutral

Personal Information

  • Location
  • Interests and Hobbies
  • Favorite Authors
    Warren Carroll, Walter Farrell, Plato, Homer, Charlotte Mason, David V. Hicks, Taylor Caldwell, Karen Glass, Peter Kreeft, CS Lewis
  • Occupation
  • School Name

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Thank you, Paul. That may be just what we need!
  2. DianaC

    Classical Education = Critical Thinking?

    I think the dialogues of Plato are very helpful in helping our students to "think critically (in a positive sense), without simply becoming cynical critics," because Socrates embodies this very act. (I start students off with the Apology, and then follow up with Crito, Phaedo, and Euthyphro over a period of a year.)
  3. DianaC

    Classical Education = Critical Thinking?

    Newman writes, “I would rather have to maintain that we ought to begin with believing everything that is offered to our acceptance, than that it is our duty to doubt everything. The former, indeed, seems the true way of learning.” I think David Hick's statement in Norms and Nobility reflects Newman's sentiment above, and also touches on Karen's statements about truth: "Take skepticism, for example. As commonly applied in modern classrooms, it kills the flowering of imagination which must accept and feed upon a premise, no matter how fantastic, before rejecting it. Premature skepticism tends to separate thinking from acting, forcing the precept to withstand an adolescent's stubborn incredulity before his is prepared to put it to the test of acting upon it. Indeed, youthful skepticism often amounts to little more than an arrogant prejudice against novel or difficult ideas. It can lead to cynicism--a sophistical (now sophisticated) belief that all ideas are relative and that none is worthy of one's wholehearted allegiance." (Karen Glass, who I noticed has commented above 🙂, has an excellent chapter in her book Consider This about the important role humility plays in learning, which I highly recommend!)
  4. DianaC

    Can We Rehabilitate the Lecture?

    I agree with you, and wholeheartedly support using lectures in high school classes. Here are some of my thoughts on lectures. 1. In my opinion, even a poorly delivered (but well prepared) lecture will usually be more useful than the "share-the-ignorance" round-table technique which is so widely encouraged in high school classes. 2. Lectures require a lot more from the teacher than round-table type discussions, because the teacher actually has to be very well-versed in his/her subject: the teacher should have a grasp of the issues at hand, should have formed some sort of reasoned opinions, and should have knowledge of related information that can only be known by some sort of research (e.g. historical circumstances, fall-out, contemporaries), and should be able to order and relate this knowledge in an engaging way. 3. I would say the most useful lectures are well prepared, are somewhat conversational in tone, include some of the speaker's personal opinions, and occasionally ask for class input.
  5. Thanks Patrick, I'll give that a try!
  6. Thanks to a friend who found this set at an estate sale, I've been reading through the first volume of 1930's author (sorry, still 20th century!) Werner Jaeger's Paideia: the Ideals of Greek Culture. I'm finding it fascinating. This is what Jaeger says he is attempting to do in these volumes: "explain the interaction between the historical process by which their [the Greeks'] character was formed and the intellectual process by which they constructed their ideal of human personality." Jaeger's focus is on the role of Greek literature.
  7. Wow! I love the alternative argument. I've always resisted the standard SAT/ACT argument because of the presuppositions, but never thought to create a positive statement which promoted actual classical benefits as well. Thank you!
  8. I found The Liberal Arts Tradition very enlightening, and our staff reads it as well. However, the first book we require our teachers to read, and one I cannot recommend highly enough, is Consider This, by Karen Glass (and I have read this book over six times, with new insight each time!). As one reads it, the "why" behind classical education becomes clear, which will illuminate the "how". Unfortunately, without the "why" as the foundation, any method will fall short.
  9. Hello, I was wondering if it would be possible to change the privacy settings for the School Center portion of the forum to make the posts only accessible by ClassicalU Forum members. When I google my name and school, my posts on the forum show up in the Google results. I wouldn't normally mind this, but since my school is involved I feel a little uneasy about posting questions and responses. I tried changing my profile name, but it doesn't appear that the system allows this. If there is a way to change my name to something less specific, please let me know, and I will do it! (I was able to change my school's name to its initials.)
  10. Hi Megan, We ended up using a free service called Calendly. It got the job done and was probably easier than the paper route, but it wasn't really ideal for scheduling multiple teachers. Patrick, I'll have to have our administrator check out Veracross. Right now we use Alma, but it sounds like Veracross may have more capabilities. Thanks for the suggestion!
  11. Do any of you use or recommend a helpful website or app to help with scheduling parent-teacher conferences? If so, please share! Many thanks, Diana Cunningham
  12. St. Bosco, the old Jesuits and their Ratio, Jacques Maritain and his Education at the Crossroads , Pius XI and his The Christian Education of Youth
  13. Warren H Carroll, founder of Christendom college and author of the best history series around! We use his Founding of Christendom for our 11th grade history text.
  14. Hello, I'm afraid I may have missed the assignment details for the upcoming class (July 10). I have the three printouts which were emailed to me, but are we to read anything particular from the book, Poetic Knowledge as well? Thanks! Diana Cunningham
  15. Would this essay I found online match up with the essay you would like us to read by Dr. Quinn? It has the same title "Education by the Muses". :: http://www.angelicum.net/classical-homeschooling-magazine/second-issue/education-by-the-muses-by-dennis-quinn/